CAN YOU ROLEPLAY THAT? aka, the grim and distressing and offensive in the collaborative writing hobby
hello, it’s me, your pal kira, back with another FANTASTIC PRODUCT TOPIC by which i mean it is my activation topic that i get into over and over: DARKNESS IN ROLEPLAY, and also, taste.
come and gaze into my orb
fucked up stuff has always happened in books. in one of my fave little books, a short intro to horror, it talks about how greek tragedies involve murder, cannibalism, and incest, but because we see this media as elevated, we do not criticize those who consume it. instead, you see a lot of criticism of the consumers of gory horror movies, who are presumed to be low-brow idiots who cannot discern between fiction and reality, and whose brains are so small that they will watch a cannibal film and be inspired/corrupted to do it.
this bring us to roleplay, our favorite. the question of taste and tastefulness and sensitivity is a perennial topic of debate. i have read lots of stuff on this, from people’s master’s theses to books. what is the point of art that is cruel? is art meant to be moral or teach a lesson? what is beauty? yadda yadda yadda. i think versions of these questions are eternally debated because, short answer, bad things sometimes stimulate people in neutral/abstract/aesthetic ways and sometimes they stimulate people in a I’m Gonna Do Some Harm ways and this has a lot more to do with the person and situation than anything else. because it’s a great big It Depends, there is endless material to ask, Depends On What?, and argue about it.
to narrow down on a question though, plebeians, i ask, Can You Roleplay That?
there seems to be some ambient feeling in the roleplay sphere, that some things might be allowed to appear in other media, such as ancient literature or prestige television, but when it comes to roleplay, your porous baby brain is too vulnerable to what it is creating, and also it is going to corrupt the reader. also, if you were a truly sensitive person, your conscience would cringe too much at “getting in character” with a terrible person or situation. you must lack taste or morality in order to be able to occupy the mental space of this character as a ‘game’. in a book, you have to occupy the villain’s headspace because your hero needs a villain, so it’s just something you endure graciously to fulfill the narrative. but in roleplay, when you could choose to be anyone and anything, any kind of hero, why do you select the offensive? why do you risk your own baby-brained moral corruption?
if you are reading this and you are a HATER OF DARKNESS, please come deliver your woke 2 opinion. if you are a LOVER OF DARKNESS, come explain your brain problems.
